Sell Sterling Silver in New York
Spoons, flatware, serving pieces, silver jewelry and coins. Here is how to read the marks, which weight counts and what to ask before you decide.
Before you agree to sell, we’ll show you what we’re buying, how we calculated your offer, and how you’ll be paid.
From a single spoon to a family silver set, we’ll show you what goes into the offer.
- Photo to be added
A STERLING mark on the back of a spoon - Photo to be added
A heavy piece on the scale, weight on display - Photo to be added
The entrance to Suite 204
How selling gold and silver works
- 1Bring in your items. Bring the pieces you’re considering selling. If you have a set, keep it together. If you have a receipt, grading report or original packaging, you can bring that along too.
- 2See what’s being evaluated. At the counter, we look at the markings, check the metal and weigh the item. If a piece has stones, a steel blade or a weighted base, ask which part of its weight is included in the offer.
- 3Review the numbers. Before you decide, ask to see the metal quality, the weight, the unit used and the rate applied. If you brought several pieces, ask which amount belongs to each one.
- 4Decide whether to sell. Review the final amount and confirm how and when you’ll be paid. If you accept, present your ID, complete the sale paperwork and ask for a copy for your records.
In New York City, a buyer of secondhand gold or silver must give the seller the weight in troy units, the metal quality and the rate per unit used for the price. Ask us to walk you through the numbers.
Example: One piece marked 925, 100.0 g
Up to 92.5 g of that weight is silver: 100.0 g × 925/1000 = 92.5 g. A weighted piece with the same total weight can contain much less silver.
Ask how much of that weight is actually silver.
Illustrative example with the nominal fineness of sterling. The actual calculation depends on the inspection and the rates applied.
Short videos
One-minute silent guides, with captions.
- Video coming soon
This candlestick is heavy. How much is silver?
- Video coming soon
Is this coin worth more than its silver?
- Video coming soon
$500 or $485. Which offer pays more?
More to know
Selling silver in New York: what to check first
Look on the back of a spoon, underneath a serving piece or inside a ring. A mark such as STERLING or 925 indicates sterling silver, which is 92.5% silver. Silver plate describes a layer of silver over another material. Bring the piece as it is if you’re unsure how to read the mark.
Heavy doesn’t always mean more silver. A candlestick marked STERLING WEIGHTED may have a sterling exterior around a heavy filling. Its total weight includes that filling. Ask how the buyer determines the silver weight used in the offer.
Selling a coin? Ask whether the offer takes the coin’s collectible value into account. Its date, rarity and condition can matter alongside its metal content. Keep it in its holder and avoid polishing it before an evaluation.
Why can my offer change from one day to the next?
Gold and silver trade in international markets. Buyers and sellers respond to changes in supply, demand, interest rates and investor activity. Industrial demand also matters for silver. A market quote can move between the time you check it at home and the time your item is evaluated. Precious-metal prices are commonly quoted in U.S. dollars per troy ounce.
Why can two buyers offer different amounts on the same day?
Start by asking what each buyer is pricing. One offer may cover metal content alone. Another may include a stone or recognize collectible value. Even when both offers are for the metal, the rate per unit and any deductions can differ.
Compare four things side by side:
- the items included
- the metal weight and quality
- the rate per unit
- the final amount you receive
Ask how long each offer is valid.
Which offer pays more?
Same items. Ask: “What is the final amount I’ll receive?”
The amounts are an example only, not an offer from our office.
What should I bring, and why is ID requested?
Bring the items you want evaluated. If you decide to sell, have identification with you. New York City secondhand dealers must verify the seller’s identity, record the purchase and obtain the seller’s signature. Call before your visit if you’re unsure whether your ID will be accepted.
If you have an old receipt, an appraisal, a coin holder or a grading report, bring it with the matching item. Before signing, check the description, the number of pieces and the agreed amount. Ask for a copy of the transaction paperwork and keep it with your payment record.
How will I be paid?
Know what you’ll receive before you say yes.
Before you accept an offer, confirm the final amount, the payment method and when the funds will be available. Ask whether any fee or deduction is already included in the quoted total.
If you are selling several items, check that the paperwork lists the pieces you agreed to sell. Keep a copy of the transaction record and the payment details. For payment options available at our office, call us before your visit.
Before you say yes
- You hear one total for a mixed lot. Ask for a breakdown by item or metal quality.
- You hear a price “per unit.” Ask which unit it is. Compare both offers using the same unit.
- Your piece has a stone. Ask whether it is included in the offer and what happens to it after the sale.
- The amount changes at the counter. Ask which input changed: the weight, the purity, the market rate or a deduction.
- Someone proposes cutting the piece or removing a stone. Ask what will be done, whether it can affect the piece and whether you want to authorize it.
- You feel rushed. Ask for the offer in writing and take time to compare it.
Questions
What can I bring?
Gold and silver jewelry, chains and bracelets, silver flatware and other silver pieces, and coins. If you have a receipt, appraisal, coin holder or grading report, bring it with the matching item. Not sure about a piece? Call before your visit.
How is it weighed?
Your items are weighed at the counter. Ask to see the weight, the unit used and the metal quality for each piece. If a piece has stones or a weighted base, ask which part of the weight is included in the offer.
What ID do I need?
If you decide to sell, have identification with you. New York City secondhand dealers must verify the seller’s identity, record the purchase and obtain the seller’s signature. If you’re unsure whether your ID will be accepted, call before your visit.
How will I be paid?
Before you accept an offer, confirm the final amount, the payment method and when the funds will be available. For payment options available at our office, call us before your visit.
Where is the office?
37 West 47 Street, Suite 204, New York, NY 10036. Use entrance No. 37 and take the elevator to the 2nd floor. Hours: Mon–Fri, 10 AM – 6 PM (New York time). Closed on weekends. If you can’t find the door, call us and we will guide you.
Bring your piece. Bring your questions.
37 West 47 Street, Suite 204New York, NY 10036Mon–Fri, 10 AM – 6 PM (New York time). Closed on weekends.